I'm going to have to go ahead and defend E.T. It follows the whole "collect stuff and get to the goal" gameplay arc, has great graphics for the time, and is based on one of the most successful movies ever.
The biggest drawback is that the pits just don't work at all and are massively distracting. I'd say that without that one drawback, the game would be considered a classic today, even with any other faults it has.