haha, I did. I started reading on page 1 the other day. It took me a few posts to wonder why people are still debating this How does it feel now, to look back on it and all that's happened?
A couple of thoughts I had throughout my read...
The numbers were bigger for Pac-Man. Pac-Man sold(over 50%)/unsold was about 7 million/5 million. E.T. sold(under 50%)/unsold was 1.5 million/3.5 million. 10 million 2600 consoles existed at the time. http://www.snopes.com/business/market/atari.asp
With that in mind, E.T.'s bad reputation, however undeserved, makes sense. Pac-Man has iterations (including the first one) that everyone can see are good, whether or not they read a manual--which not everyone does. E.T. as a video game only had the one shot.
A large number of cartridges were buried. Regardless of millions of one game or millions (or 728,000) of various, 14 trailers might not be "a sea" but it is a lot. Up to 56,000 cubic feet of matter.
For anyone who doubted the dig due to unexpectedly good condition of recovered games: This is what happens in landfills. The matter just does not break down. It's very possible to find old, full, readable newspapers in landfill digs and this has happened many times. http://humanitieslab.stanford.edu/23/174