Jump to content
  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Spider-Man: Homecoming - Spoiler-free review

Nathan Strum


I finally got around to seeing Spider-Man: Homecoming a few days ago. I was debating whether or not to go see it because frankly, I'm a little tired of Spider-Man movies. Even though some of them had their moments, and Spider-Man himself was handled pretty well, it was Peter Parker who just never really clicked. For one thing, he was always way too old, and for another, he just wasn't very likable. Tobey Maguire played him like kind of an endlessly crying jerk, and Andrew Garfield was a tortured, twenty-something emo. So even though Marvel, and not Sony, handled the creative direction for Homecoming, and his cameo was well done in Captain America: Civil War, I was just kind of over the whole Spider-Man thing.

But recently I had some time to kill, and a friend of mine hadn't seen it yet either, so we decided to check it out.

And I'm glad I did - because this is how Spider-Man should've been done all along.

Thomas Holland does a great job as Peter Parker, and this is really where the heart of the character has to be. That's what made him unique when Stan Lee created him - Spider-Man was a teenager first, and a superhero second, where previous teenage heroes were all just generic sidekicks. Peter has to figure it out and carry the burden by himself, and he's still just a kid. Holland comes across as not just a high schooler, but a young one at that. He doesn't know how to drive. He's awkward and uncertain. He makes mistakes that kids would make. Even as Spider-Man, he doesn't have things figured out yet. There's a great scene in the film where for the first time he has to get to the top of a very tall building. And it takes him a long time. It's difficult, tiring, and when he gets to the top, he's a bit freaked out because he's never been that high up before. He's not immediately swinging around effortlessly between skyscrapers. This is new for him, too.

Homecoming does a great job of putting Peter Parker back in high school, and really developing him as the character behind Spider-Man, whereas in the previous movies it often felt like the two characters weren't always the same person. It's also refreshing to see Peter having to deal with high school stuff: making friends, sitting in classes, dealing with teachers, peer pressure, etc., all while trying to figure out who he is supposed to be as Spider-Man. He's not in college, trying to earn money from the Daily Bugle, or dating some overly-hot 20-something babe. This is a more naive, innocent Spider-Man, and while the movie is not an origin story (mercifully), we're still catching him very early on as he's making mistakes and dealing with the consequences of them. It's all good stuff, and it feels honest. It feels the way Spider-Man should. He doesn't always do the right thing, but he always wants to do the right thing.

Now, one of the major weaknesses of recent superhero movies has been the villains. This is why Marvel keeps trotting Tom Hiddleston out as Loki over and over again, because he's so good at being bad. But Michael Keaton excels in this film. He's not out to rule the world, or destroy it, or be the baddest villain on the planet, or even be known as a villain. His motivations are much more grounded, believable, even understandable. His approach is smart. He doesn't make stupid mistakes, and doesn't tolerate them from subordinates. He fully believes he's doing the right thing, and has his own measure of honor. Yet he's incredibly menacing when he needs to be, and like many great movie villains, is so compelling you wouldn't mind rooting for him. He's easily one of the best superhero villains in many years, and gives me hope that Marvel is capable of reaching that level again in future films.

The rest of the cast is excellent as well. Peter's high school friends (and rivals) are all very smartly cast, well acted, and nicely updated. And yes - they all seem like high school kids. Marisa Tomei does a great turn as Aunt May (and no - I don't miss the shriveled up octogenarian from the comics at all), and easily has the best line in the movie.

Robert Downey Jr., is back as Tony Stark/Iron Man, but he doesn't dominate the movie or distract from Peter's story. He effectively serves as Peter's mentor, hoping to steer him along a better path than what he himself followed. His presence here makes sense, but anything more would be intrusive. Marvel seems to know this, as the next Spider-Man film reportedly won't have Iron Man in it.

The writing throughout the film feels natural and honest to the characters. It doesn't seem too clever - Spider-Man can be funny at times, but he doesn't always have the perfect quip or witty retort. Holland at times reminded me of a young Michael J. Fox, which is a high compliment. There are some nice nods to Spider-Man's history too, including at least one pivotal scene lifted from a classic comic story. The tone of the film is incredibly well-balanced, but most importantly - it's fun. I really enjoyed watching the movie, but best of all, I cared about what happened to the characters.

That said, it's not a perfect film as some of the special effects didn't fare too well. A number of the CG stunts felt decidedly fake, which is surprising considering how far that sort of technology has advanced. Also, the editing made it hard to follow some of the action during fight scenes. But for the most part, the action worked well, and again, it was still fun to watch.

As an aside, it's a little difficult for me to separate out the movie from the theater that I saw it in. It's one of those theaters where you can order food while you watch the film, and while generally not a problem, near the end of the movie it became really annoying as the servers came around to hand out people's checks, and would inevitably disrupt the movie by either walking in front of you, or talking to you about your own bill. That sort of thing should wait until the end credits, or just be taken care of as people exit. But I still really enjoyed the movie anyway, so that speaks pretty highly of how good it was.

Spider-Man is finally on track movie-wise. I'm really looking forward to his next solo films, provided Marvel can maintain control of them. The other Marvel films Sony is working on? Couldn't care less. Hopefully they'll learn they need Marvel's help to get these characters right. It worked here. Hopefully, they can make it work again.

Spider-Man: Homecoming gets an 8.5/10

  • Like 1


Recommended Comments

I dunno, I kinda liked the original Spider-Man, and even the sequel with Doc Ock. They probably should have reconsidered the fifteen villain pile-up that was the third movie, though.


Also, say it with me, kids... Aun-To Mei.

Share this comment

Link to comment

The Doc Ock one was very good. The original was okay, except for the Green Goblin who I thought was terrible. As I watch them now, I find Tobey Maguire annoying when not in the suit.

Share this comment

Link to comment

I realize that they will never be able to give me a movie that feels like the original 60's comics. Spidey beating Sandman by vacuuming him up or pouring the antidote down the Lizard's throat is just too small time for a major motion picture. I think this is why I like Spider-Man 2 so much. It came the closest to feeling like the old "new villain pops up with a new gimmick and Spidey has to figure out how to beat the gimmick" formula.


For the Vulture that gimmick was "When you're in the sky, you're in my element and I will beat you" so Spidey had to figure out how to ground the villain and make him fight in close quarters. Again, too small time for a big budget movie, but that's what appealed to me as a kid.


So having come to that realization, I'm going to be pretty happy with any Spider-Man movie as long as they get the PP/Spidey dynamic right. The Tobey version tried, but they were trying to do too much with those films. The Garfield version was closer, they got the humor right, but PP was too tortured. Holland is the closest we have gotten yet. The key is to remember that Spider-Man allows Peter to be someone he can never be as Peter. Spider-Man is an outlet, a release for all the pent up crap Pete is going through. Spidey has to be cool and Peter has to be a dork. Lose that dichotomy and you've lost the character.

  • Like 1

Share this comment

Link to comment

My expectations were on ground zero after the "amazing" flics, but this re-re-re-boot definitely took a turn into the right direction. Loved the scene with the kid washing his hands :)

Share this comment

Link to comment

Idunno, Spider-Man has always been my favourite superhero, even though I am not much of a comic book reader. He always made a great impression on me (your superhero can fly? Pffffft!!! Can he climb walls, walk on the ceiling, spin webs, and do acrobatics as he falls with great grace and style??)


I found the Sam Raimi versions with Tobey Maguire the best so far. Maguire to me is the perfect mixture of clumsy nerd and powerful persona; he seems genuinely awkward as Parker when he's around girls and people, yet he's funny, strong, and confident when he is Spider-Man. So what if he was a bit older? It's Sam Raimi's way of raising the stakes of the movie with some young adult issues.


Plus, those movies themselves were extremely well made. To me they were not so much "comic book movies," as they were very good action movies that happen to be about a comic book character. It felt grounded and believable and tactile and immediate, all the while without losing its epic sense of scope. Similar to the original Superman with Christopher Reeve, they will stand the test of time. That is much harder to pull off.


The "Amazing Spider-Man" movies were just a mess. I could never buy into Garfield's character.


As for the latest Homecoming movie, I enjoyed it quite a bit. I think it was very good and agree with a lot of points in your review. However, it felt just too much "comic booky." Of course, it's a comic book movie, so that's par for the course, and therefore represents a measure of success. I guess I'm just not the "Marvel Cinematic Universe" kind of guy.


I much have preferred another Sam Raimi action movie installment with Tobey Maguire. *shrug*



Share this comment

Link to comment
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Create New...