Jump to content
  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Aquaman - Spoiler-free review

Nathan Strum


Okay, everybody sing the


Aquaman, Aquaman,
Does whatever a tuna can.
Swims around, talks to fish
When he walks, his feet squish
Look out! Here's comes the Aquaman!

Is he strong? Probably
But he has to swim through fish pee
Can he ride a seahorse?
No he can't, they're too small.
Hey there – There goes the Aquaman

In the ocean deep
If a boat is around
When they fall overboard
He'll make sure they don't drown

Aquaman, Aquaman
It's green-tights-wearing Aquaman
Not first choice in a jam
Unless your foe is clam

Oh yeah - he has a magic spear, oh,
You're favorite fourth-string hero
Here comes the Aquaman!

Pretty sure that's how it goes. ;)

A couple of weeks ago I went to see Aquaman. I didn't have a lot of interest in the movie when it was announced, because, well, DC films are usually pretty awful (except for Wonder Woman). But one of the few bright spots in Justice League was watching the fun Jason Momoa was clearly having as Aquaman. Rather than being the
punching bag of Robot Chicken, (let's face it, the 70's animated Aquaman was the
sea-themed TV superhero ever), this Aquaman was fast, powerful, funny, and kicked butt. But would that character translate to a solo feature film? After all, the CEO of Warner Bros. once said, "...the worlds of DC are very different... they're steeped in realism, and they're a little bit edgier than Marvel's movies." Yeah... like that worked. :roll:

Well, if there's one thing that can be said about Aquaman, is that it's a movie not steeped in realism. Somewhere along the line, the filmmakers probably came to the conclusion that the idea of "realism" and "vast undersea empires that nobody on the surface has any idea they exist" probably didn't mesh all that well.

Aquaman is a bonkers movie. It doesn't even pretend to be realistic. It's not so much that it doesn't care, but rather it goes out of its way to be ridiculous. This is fantasy. It's a comic book brought to life with no regard for realism at all because there's nothing realistic about the subject matter. Even for comic books the whole premise is silly. Early in the film Aquaman rescues a sinking sub by swimming under it, and pushing it up out of the water. Somehow. Nuclear subs displace on the order of 48,000 tons of water. But that's no problem for Aquaman - he just pushes on it, and up it goes. His hands should just punch through the hull. I don't even think he kicks his feet when he swims. Maybe he's psionically making the water around him do all the work. But it really doesn't matter how his powers work, because the movie just lays it out there, and expects you to accept it. If you're onboard with that, then you'll probably be onboard with the rest of the movie. After all, nobody asks how Superman flies.

I should emphasize that this isn't a criticism of the film... it's merely a fact. That's what the film is. This is the universe it presents, and those are the rules that apply within it. Only the flimsiest of explanations are given for why things happen. Atlanteans can breath water, because a thing happened. Atlantis collapsed, because a thing happened. Aquaman has a magic trident, because it's a magic trident. In a way, this film is a bit like Thor in that we're given this preposterous world populated with preposterous beings, and that's just the way it is. And to the filmmakers' credit, once they establish how this world works, as wacky as it is, they're consistent with it. It's hard to break rules when you don't have any.

Fortunately, Aquaman is so bonkers that it's an entertaining movie. Again, Jason Momoa is a lot of fun to watch. The visual effects are crazy. The sea creatures are insane. The scale of the battles is epic. The costumes are ridiculous. Amber Heard looks like Mrs. Ronald McDonald. The action scenes aren't just over the top, they're over over the top. It's funny, it's silly, it's ludicrous. But it's a fun ride.

The story? Inconsequential. The villains? Forgettable. There is no logic to anything that happens in the film. But if you go into the theater with the attitude of just wanting to watch a movie for the sake of watching a movie, you'll do just fine. It unashamedly rips off more films than I was able to count: Star Wars (pick any of them), Tron, Close Encounters, 2001, Blade Runner, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Jaws (all of them - or for that matter, any movie that's ever had a shark in it), probably every Marvel movie, and so many, many more. In a way, you're really getting your money's worth, because you get to see so many other films that they borrowed from.

This is meant to be escapist entertainment, so don't expect anything particularly deep (pun intended :roll:). Apart from pointing out how much humans pollute the oceans, there's little of substance here. Of course, rather than using their advanced technology to actually help humanity solve our problems, the Atlanteans stay hidden away in their vast, underwater cities complaining about it.

Even when they decide to declare war on humanity, they don't actually tell us. And I'm pretty sure they actually say something along the lines of "this will teach them a lesson", but without actually, you know... teaching us a lesson.

Even at the end of the film, humans still don't believe Atlantis exists, despite everyone already having known about Aquaman because of the events in Justice League. None of it makes much sense, so just try not to think about it. Just enjoy the spectacle, because it has plenty of that.

The scene with Aquaman riding a giant crab alone is worth the cost of admission.

Aquaman is worth seeing in the theater, because of the scope and scale of everything. It's completely ridiculous. It doesn't make any sense. But that's okay, because it's a comic book movie, and it makes Aquaman a pretty cool character. Plus, based on the

trailers, it's apparently setting us up for the new tone for the DC Universe: Wacky!

Aquaman gets 7/10, because... why not? Now if they can just fix Batman and Superman.

Does whatever a tuna can...get it? Tuna can!

Sometimes, I crack me up. :D



Recommended Comments

Maybe this is the beginning of DC finally understanding that with a back catalog as large as theirs, and plans to make a million movies, they are much better served by making different types of movies.


In the same way that marvel has created movies with different tones (First Avenger - period piece; Winter Soldier - political thriller; Ant Man - caper flick, Guardians of the Galaxy - humorous, etc) DC could easily do something similar with it's characters: Batman - gritty (check!), Wonder Woman - optimistic (check!), Aquaman - bonkers (check!). They would just need to figure out how Superman (actually patriotic, as opposed to jingoistic) and the Flash (flashy?) fit into the milieu.


So it seems like they are already on their way, even if they don't know they are.


That's my hope anyway! Aquaman and Wonder Woman were both *really* fun. WW was actually a terrific movie, and Aquaman was just so silly that it was totally worth it and I would be *happy* to see something similar.

Share this comment

Link to comment

Based on Justice League, it looked like Flash would be DC's comedic film. For Superman, they really need to rethink their whole approach. The character really hasn't been right in the movies since Chris Reeve's first film. De-powering him some so he's more in line with the Fleischer cartoons wouldn't hurt. But getting the tone (and casting) right would be critical. They just need to forget that Justice League ever happened, and reboot the character with a new actor.

Share this comment

Link to comment

I would actually love to see Henry Cavill with an appropriate story, decent script and no moustache. He's not as "bumbly" as I would like when he portrays Clark, but with the right director (and script and story) who knows? I feel like they really haven't served him, or the character well. I hope that he doesn't get too bogged down in playing Geralt.


It's a testament to the quality of the 1978 superman movie, and DC's ineptitude, that they have not been able to do justice to the character in the movies since then.

Share this comment

Link to comment

So ... How does Superman fly? Inquiring minds want to know. :grin:


He's made entirely of little tiny helicopters, which are the size of molecules.

Share this comment

Link to comment


He's made entirely of little tiny helicopters, which are the size of molecules.


OMG! That explains so much!!! :lol:

Share this comment

Link to comment
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Create New...