I'm avoiding the forum discussions about this, because I don't see any point in adding my voice to the noise there. I'd rather let Artie comment, since he has a longer history with Atari than I do, since he was built by them.
That said...
My concerns are: who is really running Atari, what are their actual goals, and what happens if they fail to meet them? Does Wade Rosen have free reign, or is he on a leash with Atari's board of Directors? What is he expected to accomplish, and in what time frame, and what happens if that fails? Are they expecting to attain a certain level of profitability in a given number of years? And even if they do, is the goal to maintain and build on that, or make Atari an attractive property for eventual buyout? Is Rosen in this for the long haul, or if he gets a better/more prestigious offer from another company, is he going to jump ship? Is there a succession plan in place for that possibility? These are questions that there are already answers to, because these discussions have already happened (or they're not doing their jobs). But we'll never know the actual answers, until the events play out. They can "say" anything in interviews or press releases. But that means nothing.
AtariAge is a small piece of the Atari puzzle, and one that could be easily discarded or abandoned in a heartbeat. "Sorry Al - but the numbers just aren't adding up this quarter for us to keep you around."
I'm not criticizing Al's decision to sell to Atari. I think it's (potentially) a great opportunity for him, and I know that AtariAge has pretty-much taken over his life. He certainly didn't intend for that to happen, and burnout is going to be inevitable. Some may think, "Yeah - but that's the dream! Getting to do your hobby for a living!" but the problem is, AtariAge isn't a reliable, predictable, or sustainable source of income. It's wholly reliant on programmers being willing to donate their time to create games, and a community being willing to pay money to purchase enough of those games to cover not only the production costs of the games themselves (which is considerable), but pay to keep AA itself up and running, and then put food on the table. It's a terrible way to try to earn a living. A steady paycheck has to be of tremendous relief to Albert, not to mention the possibility of getting some much-needed help.
Clearly, Al's had enough interaction with Atari to trust them to take over ownership of AA. But Atari now owns this forum, which includes the software driving this blog (I maintain that I own the content, however). And they can pull the plug tomorrow if they choose to do so. I think that's the big, overarching fear most people have. Or that Atari will irreparably damage the forum through censorship, ads, or other means. However, I'm not as doom-and-gloom about that as some others may be. This is the very nature of the internet. Communities come and go all the time. Usually, the people who want to keep together simply move on to another location and continue on. Been there, done that. Several times. I hope AtariAge will continue on though. But the world won't end if it doesn't. Everyone who wants to, will turn up somewhere. People are resilient like that.
Unlike Albert, I do not trust Atari. They have too checkered of a history to warrant it. As far as I'm concerned, Atari has yet to prove they're a different company. They may be. But the 2600+ is a yet-another example of a product from a company that just doesn't "get it". They're not paying attention to the details, which means at some level, they don't care enough. And if they don't care enough about that... what else won't they care about?
Optimistically, maybe this is still part of their learning curve. Certainly, Atari has a lot of learning to do to pull itself out of the mire. Maybe Rosen will turn into the visionary Atari has been lacking for 40+ years. More than anything else, a company like Atari needs someone with a clear and correct vision and the ability to act on it. We'll see how it goes. I'd like to see the return of a competent Atari. It'd be fun to want to buy one of their products again.
But I'm going to start backing up my blog entries.