I remember back sometime late 1996/early '97 I bought a handful of sealed games for like $40 from someone online (before people were selling much on ebay)
That site reminds me of the list I bought from back then... unfortunately the titles were all common/uncommon, probably overstock from K-B Toys , I don't recall if they had any rares, but back then I didn't know what the rare titles were. Was just excited I was able to buy some games that I wanted when I was a kid...