Seeming as though you want to dredge up history (re: posts 5 and 14) perhaps I should ‘return the favour’, after all…One good turn deserves another, as the old line goes
I seem to remember back in the annals of Atariage history (sorry can’t be arsed or bothered to find the link or use the search service) that a certain person (who shall remain nameless) wanted to sell his Atari 8bit disk games on ebay (I believe there was a thread about said auction/listing on this v. forum)
Now, you may ask, what’s wrong with that, however there was something very interesting regarding the disks…..According to the person placing the auction/listing that the disks were ‘all originals’ (i.e. not pirate/copies) however in the 20 years or so that they’d kept them they had somehow magically ‘lost their original labels’, if I recall the thread/auction correctly all or most of the disks had ‘lost all their original labels’ (hence the fact that all the disks had homebrew or self written labels attached to the ‘original disks’), which naturally or obviously lead to suggestions that the disks might not be as ‘original’ as the auction seemed to state or infer/imply
I will, for the purpose of this post refrain from using the exact words that suggested that the disks were not as ‘original’ as the auction seemed to state, and only because I seem to recall or remember that a certain person here (who shall remain nameless) started spitting his dummy out and threatened anyone that suggested that the disks were not originals with legal action (I guess the certain persons angle would have been, suing them for libel, slander or defamation or similar)
Perhaps the person concerned can remind me, did they manage to sell the disks on eBay, or did eBay somehow get wind that the disks might not be ‘originals’ as stated in the listing/auction and promptly removed the auction or listing
Couple of reasons why I bring this up now (apart from dredging up history like the person concerned seems to want to) firstly, I still have all my old boot menu disks and dos/PD disks from when I was heavy into actually using my A8 hardware (some 500 plus disks) I’d say that over ¾’s of those disks are 20 years or older and the remainder are no later then 1997/8, most of the disks were put in an industrial supplies box with some other stuff and another large industrial box placed on top of that box (the ones with the disks in)
Late last year I decided to see if the disks were OK, so I dug the box out and thumbed through all the disks and guess what, not a single one had managed to loose their original label
Interesting that none of my disks managed to lose their original labels yet in a certain persons eBay auction/listing, all or most of their disks had ‘magically’ lost their original labels
The 2nd reason why I bought this up, If as the person concerned claimed, that the disks they were selling on eBay were ‘originals’ then why did they feel the need to threaten people with legal action and since they did (if I recall correctly) post comments in that thread, why didn’t the person concerned provide evidence to back up their claim that the disks were indeed originals….After all if you have nothing to hide (i.e. the disks were indeed originals) then you have nothing to fear by providing evidence to back up your claim
If eBay did get wind of the fact that the disks that the person concerned was trying to sell were not ‘originals’ as the person claimed they were in the auction and therefore removed the auction, why didn’t the person concerned appeal the removal and get the auction reinstated or just re-advertise the disks, if as the original auction claimed that all the disks were ‘originals’